By Hamza Hendawi
BARRING the unexpected, the economy and the stock market are virtually certain to show an improvement this year compared to 1997, according to bankers, economists and market traders. Some of them, however, appeared to suggest that a better performance in 1998 should not be seen as an impressive feat, given 1997’s overall poor showing.
Speaking to the Cyprus Mail, they were unwilling or reluctant to agree with the government’s recent forecast that the economy would grow by 4.5 per cent this year, but were careful not to dismiss it as a pipe dream.
February’s presidential election will have little or no impact on the economy, they said, save a temporary boost in investors’ confidence and spending which had traditionally followed similar events in the past.
The year 1998 is widely viewed in Cyprus as a crunch year, and that has little to do with the presidential polls. In fact, it has more to do with the psychologically significant opening in April of accession talks with the European Union, and the potentially explosive arrival in the summer of Russian anti-aircraft missiles whose deployment, if Ankara’s threats are to be taken seriously, will trigger a preemptive military strike by Turkey.
The year 1998 is also important because many believe that a major revival in international interest led by the UN and the United States to solve the 23-year-old Cyprus problem will peak in the months which immediately follow the presidential election with an agreement – or indeed a final breakdown in negotiations – possibly in place before the year is out.
“1998 is going to be a better year than 1997, driven mainly by improved tourism,” according to economist Marios Clerides, Senior Manager, Planning & Research, at the Hellenic Bank. “There will be better growth, inflation will be maintained at 1997 levels and unemployment will become slightly lower.”
“Agriculture is too small to matter,” he said, alluding to the persistent drought which has badly hit the sector and the resultant fall in farm exports.
“But we are worried about the growing budget deficit,” Clerides said, referring to the staggering £550.3 million shortfall projected by the government in the 1998 budget.
Another economist, Maria Zambarloukou, deputy manager of the Bank of Cyprus’ Planning Division, agreed that 1998 would see an improvement on 1997.
“Our forecast for GDP growth in 1998 is slightly lower (than the government’s), but we do know that it is going to be a better year.
“We reckon 3.5 per cent, but then we do have to be conservative as a bank. We are not saying that 4.5 per cent cannot be reached, what we are saying is that this depends on a lot of factors which we cannot forecast at the moment.”
Zambarloukou also dismissed the widespread notion that economic activity during the months of January and February would be slow in the run-up to the election and then the wait-and-see period which would follow.
“The presidential elections will not put things on hold since January and February are very slow months in terms of tourism and spending. So, if the economy slows down in those two months it would be due to seasonal factors rather than the election,” she said.
A slightly different view on the possible impact of the election is held by Ioannis Andronikos, a broker at Nicosia-based Suphire Stockbrokers Ltd.
“At least 1998 is an election year and the picture will become clearer,” he said. “Usually in Cyprus a boom follows an election and I hope that 1998 will not be an exception.”
But Clerides, the Hellenic Bank’s senior economist, believes the island’s economic policies are largely charted by the civil service, rather than politicians, thus allowing new political leaderships room for only cosmetic changes in how the economy is run.
But if there is some uncertainty about economic growth in 1998, everyone seems to agree that the Cyprus stock market will have a good year in 1998.
“It was a bad year (1997) in the market, but we believe that we’ll have a considerably better year in 1998,” said Nicos Efrem, a prominent stockbroker and a 14-year veteran of the market. Efrem’s positive forecast for 1998, however, is made against a backdrop of serious complaints about how the bourse is being run.
“Neither the government nor the Chamber of Commerce are doing enough to encourage more companies to seek a listing,” he said.
“It is also a very expensive market. The Cyprus Stock Exchange charges brokerages a lot and brokers charge customers a lot. There is also a great deal of bureaucracy involved in buying and selling.”
Echoing similarly upbeat sentiments on the market’s 1998 prospects is Nicos Severis, chairman of Sigma-Severis & Athienitis Securities Ltd, one of the island’s top brokerages.
In an article published in the September issue of Accountancy Cyprus, Severis predicts 4 per cent GDP growth in 1998 and tourism to break the record set in 1995, when an unprecedented 2.2 million foreign tourists came to Cyprus.
“The political developments are far from negative and even though Cypriot investors do not sound positive on this front, we have very strong indications from foreign investors that they feel comfortable with the political risk,” he wrote, alluding to the Cyprus problem.
He said the bourse was set to recover in 1998, adding that the road to recovery began with the introduction in early 1997 of government debts into the market.
“This will draw institutional funds into the market and, importantly, attract foreign investors. on the one hand, the Cyprus government debt carries an enviable AA rating from the international rating agencies,” he said.
“The third factor that will propel the CSE is that by the year’s end or by the first quarter (of 1998) at the latest, Cyprus will most probably be part of the International Finance Corporation Worldwide Emerging Markets Index.
“It is difficult to quantify what this will mean, but our estimate is that in excess of £250 million will, over a short period of time, find their way to the CSE,” he wrote.
The article by Severis, one of the island’s top financiers, does not touch on some of the bureaucratic problems bedeviling the market since it became official in March 1996.
Some of these problems are expected to be solved when a joint committee comprising representatives from the bourse, brokers and the government meet on January 15 to adopt recommendations to inject life into the market.
“The legislation which came into force in March 1996 made the market a bureaucratic nightmare with charges made very high and investors having to pay high fees. That, in turn, pushed investors away,” he said.
“We need drastic measures to encourage companies to list on the market; I don’t think there will be much goings-on in 1998, but hopefully the (EU) accession talks will encourage some,” he said.
“We’ve attracted no foreign investments to speak of.
“I cannot generalise here, but the foreign investors who approached us (Suphire Ltd) eventually decided not to enter the market because it is small and closed. They were not worried about getting into the market, but were worried about the exit routes.”