European Court verdict a ‘powerful weapon’ in future talks

THE VERDICT of the European Court of Human Rights finding Turkey guilty of violations of human rights in Cyprus opens new horizons for the solution of the Cyprus problem, President Glafcos Clerides said yesterday.

“The Court by its ruling has given us a powerful weapon in the negotiations for a solution and we are going to examine the entire text of the decision very thoroughly to see how to make the most out of it,” Clerides said.

“The Court ruling is of immense importance, it considers Turkey responsible for human rights violations in the self-styled Turkish Cypriot regime in occupied Cyprus, and describes this regime as a subordinate local administration to Turkey,” the President said.

Clerides said he would call a meeting of the National Council for “a constructive discussion” on the matter.

“Now we have a formal decision by the European Court saying that what Denktash wants, such as to deny refugees the right to return to their homes, violates the European Convention of Human Rights,” he said.

Addressing a news conference earlier yesterday, Attorney-general Alecos Markides described the ruling as the greatest legal victory for Cyprus against Turkey since 1974.

In its ruling on Thursday, the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg stung Turkey with a verdict finding her guilty of gross violations of human rights in Cyprus.

The decision comes as a serious blow to Ankara’s application to join the EU – and is the strongest ever denunciation of its human rights record in recent history.

Cyprus took Turkey to the European court in 1994. Six-and-a-half years later, in a judgment passed by 16 votes to one, the Strasbourg court ruled that Turkey had violated 14 articles of the convention, including the right to life, the right to liberty and security, the right to freedom of thought and the right to freedom of expression.

“It is now up to the National Council to decide how to take advantage of that decision,” Markides said yesterday.

The Attorney-general, who led the government’s legal team in Strasburg, said the decision was the biggest and most important case ever heard by the court.

But when asked how this decision could be put into effect, Markides said: “There is still a long way to go.”

This was the first time the court had found a member of the Council of Europe guilty over mass violations of human rights in a fellow member country. But it was difficult to say what measures the court would take to implement its decision, Markides explained.

“However, from the moment the decision was announced yesterday, Turkey has a responsibility to comply with that decision and to restore human rights in northern Cyprus,” Markides said categorically.

“The court is now supposed to ensure just satisfaction of the case, but what that would mean for Cyprus at the end of the day I can’t say. It could take a few years before there is a development,” Markides said.

The court has not yet decided whether to fine Turkey and will issue a final verdict in a few months time. As a signatory to the Human Rights Convention and a member of the Council of Europe, Ankara must comply with the final ruling.

Markides said that his office was looking into ways of achieving just satisfaction, but did not elaborate.

He added that refusal by Turkey to comply with the court’s decision would lead to an unbridgeable gap between her and the Council of Europe.

Political parties in Nicosia yesterday all hailed the court’s verdict and said it was a card the government should play to strengthen Nicosia’s bargaining position in settlement negotiations.

Greece too welcomed the Court’s condemnation of Turkey and called for an enforcement of the verdict.

“The decision by the European Court is of historical importance,” Greek Government Spokesman Demetris Reppas said.

But Turkish Prime Minister Bulent Ecevit dismissed the Court’s decision as a mistake, arguing the judgment would not contribute to a settlement on the island.

“Cyprus’s questions are not legal but political,” he said “The questions can only be solved if the two sides enter into a dialogue.”

“Cyprus has two independent states,” said Ecevit, who ordered the 1974 invasion. “Even though many nations do not recognise this, it is a reality… The decision made by the European Court of Human Rights does not meet the realities of Cyprus.”

A Turkish government official added he feared the verdict could be politically exploited.

The verdict includes condemnation of Turkey for mass violation of the right to abode of displaced persons, for mass violation of the right of displaced persons to own property and for mass violations of the rights of the missing persons – not because there was testimony that Turkey killed them or was still holding them, but because it refuses to investigate their fate.