May I thank the High Commissioner for his studied piece on global warming (‘Copenhagen Climate Summit: why we need 2C’, Sunday Mail, October 24). Not surprisingly, this follows Her Majesty’s Governments position on the subject.
Unfortunately, these thoughts are very flawed. The position his arguments follow is that of the International Governments Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). This panel involves 1,000 scientists who are experts in their field. Sadly this panel is totally influenced by individual governments, each of which has their axes to grind. The panel has a computer based climate model which is trying to mirror the real world. The model is not able to predict with any accuracy what is really happening.
The measurements made continuously by satellites show a totally different story to the IPCC predictions. These satellite predictions also have computer programs which may be inaccurate but these measurements are not in any way influenced by politicians.
The High Commissioner’s arguments are flawed on several points. The most important is the belief that global warming can be controlled at 2C. And that the world has several decades in which to control the CO2 levels. The rate of melting of the polar ice caps is happening so rapidly that the Arctic ice will be gone in as few as 10 years.
Then the sun’s heating effect will no longer be used melting the ice but in warming the sea. For those of you have forgotten their physics, it takes 80 times the energy to melt one gram of ice than to heat one gram of water 1C. Additionally the ice cover reflects 80 per cent of the sun’s energy; the sea only reflects 20 per cent. I didn’t mention that on melting, the ice on the land say in Greenland will raise sea levels!
Additionally there are other factors than CO2 which cause global heating and cooling. An important cooling effect is pollution caused by fossil fuel use. It can be seen in the atmosphere in Cyprus. The effect is to reduce the sun’s energy which reaches the Earth. Many of you in summer will have realised that there is a correlation between pollution and cooler days. Any sudden reduction in the world’s use of fossil fuels will exacerbate global warming.
When the ice has gone, sea temperature will rise very quickly and certainly more that 2C and there will be no going back to cooler times. The Earth will settle down to a higher temperature and life will have to adjust or die. To avoid the latter we humans, will need as much energy as possible to counter the effects of the heat and the rise in sea levels. As the High Commissioner has pointed out, this energy needs to be mainly from what are called renewables.
Cyprus has some advantages, principally solar energy which the island uses extensively and which it could use even more for the generation of electricity. However, I do hope the island will not follow the UK government’s dash for wind or indigestion will follow. Wind power is already in use in Cyprus in specialised areas such as pumping water. In this use it is effective. For based load use generating electricity it is useless. In the UK, it generates electricity only 25 per cent of the time. Every wind farm needs a back-up power station which could produce the electricity needed without the wind farm.
Cyprus should asked the French to provide a nuclear station to guarantee enough relatively cheap power and to pursue solar powered generation.
Edwin R. Lynas,
Paphos